I have STIs on both of my Bike Fridays, and they haven't been any problem at all. I have bar end shifters on my other touring bike, and you're right - those are more bomb-proof. But I definitely have to remember which bike I'm riding when I go to shift.

My advice is to get whichever shifters you think will make you more comfortable. (Yes, I know, that doesn't help!)

Congrats on your new ride!

--- Denise