Big Fish was good/odd - I'd have to be in a very specific mood to sit thru it. I think the other responses take care of that one.

I really like Sleepy Hollow. I do tend toward spooking myself, and wouldn't watch something like that when I'm home alone on a dark, windy night. However, I do find that as long as I watch thru to the end and see how it resolves, then I'm okay - it wraps everything up so I don't get freaked out by the 'what if' of lose ends Oh, and Christopher Walken is freaky amazing, gotta love him.

My October/November must watch movies include Sleepy Hollow & Brotherhood of the Wolf.