My fitter charged $150, 2 years ago, for my refit. she checked my flexibility, spent a lot of time talking to me about my goals and type of riding.

However, even if you didn't pay for the fit she is trained by Serotta and is using the Serotta philosophy of fitting.

One tip from the Andy Pruitt book, on the hoods "your wrist should be in a neutral, handshake position as much as possible. If your wrist angles toward the thumb or little finger, you'll experience numbing nerve pressure"

In the picture your hands look like they're angling toward your thumbs. If you ride that way it could be the cause of your problem.

If you kept the same handlebars were they the right size? Also, was the new fork the same as the original?

Your position looks good, better than a lot of riders I see, you have a nice flat back, flat shoulders, not to stretched.

Andy Pruitt says reach is hard to dial in for any fitter because it is so personal, so I still say give it some time before you make any changes.