I wonder if it would be feasible to take a very, very fine steel wool (the type used by jewelers) to scuff the surface? This is just a guess, because the only leatherworking I've done has been with boots, but after oiling, the 'blackness' would still be there, it'd just be a hair rougher. Any thoughts?

I'm gonna propose to my DPITA that I get the Brooks as a gift to myself after managing the LIVESTRONG ride Sunday. My parts will be begging for any kind of relief, anyway