nay... the undie style negates a lot of the utility of having a chamois - IMHO they'd at least need to be "boy shorts" length and tight enough around the leg hole to stay put to be of any use. Both those pairs look like they might rub in uncomfortable places. She looks like she's been sucked into the "padding" myth of cycling shorts.... it's not about padding anything (in fact as many people find out highly padded shorts can be a major liability for soft tissue pressure and discomfort), but about creating a seamless place for your tender parts to be gliding along on... puts on querulous oldster voice.... I remember when cycling shorts had real chamois leather in them and weren't padded in the slightest (ok, ok... I never had a pair with real chamois, but I did have some with a synthetic, washable, equivalent that were basically unpadded)