Hi there- new rider looking to purchase my first road bicycle and very excited to be joining this community!

I have my eye on two NEW bikes and would love feedback. The first is a 2011 Trek Madone 4.5 (WSD) Carbon with Shimano 105 components (in feminine colors). The second is a Women's 2012 Cannondale CAAD 10 3 (alloy/carbon) with Shimano Ultegra components (in slightly more masculine colors).

I like the way both of them ride. I also know I may not have this bicycle forever so also need to consider the resale value of both bikes.

Any feedback on the comparison of these two is welcome - specifically on whether the carbon vs components issue can--or should--take precedence, all things equal and giving consideration to which might hold its value better.

Thanks much!