Today I tried a few different saddles - Fizik - don't remember which model but it had a long groove down the middle ... Horrible... couldn't stand it even on the trainer.

Brooks Team Pro Mens - My sitbones loved it, but it had the same contact/chafing points as any other Brooks I've tried.

On a whim, I grabbed one of the Adamo noseless saddles not really expecting anything good because it seemed rather narrow, but it took about 5 seconds on the trainer to go "Oh, now this is worth trying!" The guy at the store couldn't help himself and had to give it a go as well, and surprised himself by finding it rather nice.

So this is what I'm trying for now. Thanks for the input everyone. I'll let you know how it works out.