So glad for this thread. I've been struggling since Friday with my decision to remove the clipless pedals from my commuter. Thoughts of not being a real cyclists without being clicked in, trying to decide if I should impose a deadline to put them back on. All silly, ridiculous thoughts, really.

This thread plus today's commute on flat pedals made it all so clear. This is the right decision for me, on this bike, for this route. So nice to not be constantly worrying about my feet, or balancing one unclipped foot on a pedal. No problems with the hills - even where on Friday I stopped at one place and pushed bike up - mainly due to being afraid I'd lose momentum and tip over unable to get foot out while standing and mashing.

I'll continue to use the clipless on the road bike, and work towards them on the mountain bike. I know someday I will get more instinctual. But for my commute with lots of starts and stops, lots of traffic. I feel better in flats.

But am going to check out some of these recommended pedals. Was looking at BMX type - do the little spikes tear up soles of shoes? Seems like they would.