Quote Originally Posted by OakLeaf View Post
bellissima, what do the zones actually mean?

It seems to me, as I said before, that my old old Garmin derived mine reasonably accurately, at least as they correspond to my perceived exertion.

My MHR for running is around 188, resting around 50, but it goes up pretty quickly with any activity. Zone 1 starts at 86 according to the Garmin, which is about where it goes at moderately brisk walking. But then Zone 2 doesn't start until 146, which is about where my respiration rate starts to increase appreciably. I can't run at all, not even a slow jog, with a HR below around 135, and if I can keep it there, I do NOT feel like I'm working.

So from there, zones 2 through 5 are quite narrow - 9 or 10 bpm. That doesn't make a lot of sense, and it's tough when I'm supposed to stay in zone 3, for instance ... but again, it works with my perceived exertion.

What's your take???
For me zones 1 and 2 are very similar, zone 2 is quite easy and it really doesn’t feel like much work is being done, in the same hand is hard to stay at this zone and it takes some practice as any increase on effort will take me to zone 3, so I would need to pay attention to my computer if I want to stay at zone 2, zone 3 is where I start to feel as I am working and find that if I don’t pay attention I tend to gravitate towards this zone, zone 4 feels hard, it takes concentration to maintain for long periods of time. You zones seem to be somewhat off, If we calculate your zones by just using your MAX HR being 188 and using percentages your zones may look similar to: Zone 1 (Active Recovery) 94-112, Zone 2 (Endurance) 113-131, Zone 3 (Tempo) 132-149, Zone 4 (Threshold) 150-168, Zone 5 169-188. At 146 bpm you would be at the upper part of zone 3. The best way to calculate your zones is by doing a test and calculating your actual threshold.