We've only adopted 1 shelter cat...the rest of them have found us (we have sucker written on our foreheads in an invisible script that only cats can read, apparently). It was very difficult taking just 1 home.

Badger, whichever kitty you choose is going to be SO lucky, from the sound of it. Like others have said, all of these kitties are deserving and this will be one less kitty without a loving home. This is a wonderful thing!