1992 Legacy hit a deer and a 1998 Legacy, 110k miles and going. We have not had an Outback. I like the low roof for loading gear. My kayak fits in the back. In fact, I can shuttle for two with both kayaks in the back. My issue with the subarus has been the power. Ours have always been underpowered but the gas mileage is closer to 30 mpg. We have been using a bike rack on the hatch of the wagon to avoid wind issues. Repair is reasonable.

When thinking of upgrade we have considered tha Passat and Volvo xc70. Not sure about VW repair costs. But the new Outbacks look nice. Always looking for AWD.

We also have a truck, a Toyota Tacoma SR5. It is a business vehicle, so it doesn't go out to play, but it can haul stuff and has power. Gas mileage is loooowww.

Sarah