Wow, this is tons to consider. Thanks, everyone! I like the Honda Element, too, although it's a bit boxy for my taste. The 4-Runner is a good choice for us, I think. His daily commute is only about five miles, if that. He'd ride more, but the road is treacherous for traffic in spite of the bike lanes, and now it's getting dark before he gets off.

Thanks, everyone! I'll keep you updated if we get a new bike carrier. <g>

Roxy