Quote Originally Posted by radicalrye View Post
Have you considered getting the Keen SPD sandals? They are more comfortable than pretty much any cycling shoe. They aren't the best if you're in really cold weather, but you could always do like Sheldon Brown and wear them year round with thick wool socks

Haven't tried it but you may even be able to put booties on over them as well.
+1 on the Keens.
I wear mine even in the winter. I wear Wolly Bully thick wool socks and I just bought a pair of winter cycling booties to put over them. Ordered them a size bigger than my normal cycling shoe and they slip right over. I love the Keens even better than my expensive Sidi road shoes. They're the only shoe I wear now (on multi-day trips, in triathlons, commuting, etc). They may look silly in winter and on my carbon fiber tri bike- but I don't care about looks- I care about comfort!