Thanks for all the replies. I guess I should look at a new stem then.

It's very possible that you've become more flexible as you've ridden more. To address that, however, I would start with your current bike. I'd note that you should not use saddle setback to lengthen your reach. Your saddle position is largely a function of proper knee position over your pedals. Instead, you will probably want to start with a longer stem but be sure to increase your stem in small increments. You might also be able to handle a bit more saddle to bars drop. I'd start with the stem first though.
Indysteel: What sort of a increase do you think would be reasonable to start with?

I think I may have the LBS look at my saddle/pedal set up as well and see that I make sure that is right before changing anything else.