I have been struggling forever trying to find the right orthotics. I have been using lime green Superfeet in my cycling shoes, but I want to start running again. My PT isn't real helpful here, and when I went to a podiatrist before, they said the over the counter ones would be fine for me. But which ones? The ones that podiatrist suggested (Powerstep) didn't have a good arch support (aka it collapsed when the PT pressed on it). Superfeet are rigid and have good support but it would be like running on a concrete floor! I tried running in them and it doesn't help. If I can't figure it out I'll be coating the superfeet with some kind of happy cushion, because that's what I need, good arch support with happy cushion. Anyone have any luck? I see so many on the internet that I'm too afraid to try any. I haven't tried any of the other types of superfeet-just the light green ones.

Thanks in advance ! Karin