So I ended up finding some conti gp4000 tires for a good price on ebay. I just tried them yesterday and they are like BUTTA! What great tires! They corner well, are fast, and are soooo smooth. I can't believe I was torturing myself with those Bontragers for so long. I love these tires!

I think I am 2 MPH faster with these things and my bike feels lighter!