I'm starting to try a minimalist approach. I have a few other pairs of shoes, but honestly I never loved any as much as my original SIDI Dominator 5 purchase. So much so that they finally wore out the fabric and padding in the back and the velcro was almost useless... so I purchased the exact same shoe, just in the modern color.
2007, meet 2012. (And thanks, TE, for the 20% sale!)

-- gnat! (and I'm keeping the old ones for muddy cx races, for sure)
Windsor: 2010 S-Works Ruby
Pantysgawn: 2011 S-Works Stumpjumper 29er
Whiz!: 2013 S-Works Crux (Singlespeed)
Boucheron: 2009 S-Works Tricross
Haloumi: 2013 Tern P7i
Kraft: 2009 Singlecross
Gouda: 2005 Electra Betty
Roquefort: 1974 Stella SX-73