When my dear old Subaru Legacy was on it's last legs, I was considering an Element.
There were only 2 things that I didn't like: 1. The safety pillar was "made" out of the overlapping doors rather than being part of the roll cage. 2. The AWD version cost more than the Subaru Impreza and I couldn't get AWD and manual transmission. (2005)
My old honda Accord was a great car, and since the Element is built from a Civic (also a great car) I had no concerns about quality. But I did worry about the safety pillar, the price, and I'm a stick-shift afficionado. ("if it don't clutch, it ain't much")
So I got Subi #3, but I still have a little lust in my soul for an Element...
"If Americans want to live the American Dream, they should go to Denmark." - Richard Wilkinson