Brooks Imperial?

[Catrin]

Has anyone any experience with the Brooks Imperial saddle? I was told that Brooks recently brought this design back, probably feeling the heat of that other saddle company I was asking about Apparently the original design hails from the late 1800s. My build kit includes the B17 S Imperial with rails.

[KnottedYet]

Did you do the "cut out test"?

Do you need a cut out?

[Catrin]

Did you do the "cut out test"?

Do you need a cut out?

I liked the over feel of the Selle-An-Anatomica but found it too long and the nose too narrow. When I learned that Brooks had a B-17 S that was similar it seemed the best of both worlds.

What is the cut out test?

[KnottedYet]

Find a wooden chair or stone bench or other very hard and unyielding seating surface.

Sit on it.

Hinge forward at your hips (don't bend your back) until you can rest your elbows on your knees.

Stay that way for a few minutes.

If your "soft tissues" object to this treatment, it is likely you would benefit from a saddle with a cutout.

If your "soft tissues" (we're talkin' labia here, ok?) have no extraordinary issues, it is likely that a cutout is unnecessary, and you might end up being one of the folks who complains about the rubbing or pinching of the edges of the cut-out. (more trouble than it is worth)

Nothing is written in stone, ever. But it's helpful to know a bit about tissue volume. Soft tissue complaints during the test should be taken seriously.

[Catrin]

Find a wooden chair or stone bench or other very hard and unyielding seating surface.

Sit on it.

Hinge forward at your hips (don't bend your back) until you can rest your elbows on your knees.

Stay that way for a few minutes.

If your "soft tissues" object to this treatment, it is likely you would benefit from a saddle with a cutout.

If your "soft tissues" (we're talkin' labia here, ok?) have no extraordinary issues, it is likely that a cutout is unnecessary, and you might end up being one of the folks who complains about the rubbing or pinching of the edges of the cut-out. (more trouble than it is worth)

Nothing is written in stone, ever. But it's helpful to know a bit about tissue volume. Soft tissue complaints during the test should be taken seriously.

I will try this as soon as I find an appropriate surface. I do have a wooden chair, but the seat is quite curved, and I want to find a flat surface for this test. I think my club has a bench that would be appropriate

[Catrin]

I did the "cut out" test as described and there was no discomfort at all. So I don't need the Imperial...I suspect the regular B-17 saddle is less expensive than the Imperial

[roguedog]

I know there's preference for wallbike.com but, if you're price sensitive, i found brooks saddles here: http://www.sjscycles.co.uk/category....mp=16&sfile=1=

the price has risen since i last purchased prob due the exchange rate . dollar was slightly stronger so i ended getting b17s for a little over $50. course i knew i liked brooks saddles so if you're unsure wallbike might be the place to go.

i think wallbike still has the nice exchange policy??