Need some help from the 50+ Ladies

[ASammy1]

Hi Ladies!

My mother (age 52) recently got a new job and it's only 3 miles from her house. She has expressed an interest in getting a bike to go back and forth to work. She has asked for my help in finding one that will be comfortable for her at her level. I haven't seen her on a bike since the early 80s, so I'm thinking beginner. She also has Crohn's Disease and in the past year was diagnosed with Rheumatoid Arthritis. The RA sometimes affects her hips also.

So my question is... Which bike would you recommend? I am very proud of her for taking such an active role in getting herself healthy. She recently started doing Yoga and she seems to think it's helping with the RA.

I'm not sure how to help her. She lives 3 states away and the only advice I've given her so far is to find one she likes with a comfortable saddle. She's feeling very overwhelmed by all the different types of bikes that are out there and doesn't want to go to teh LBS until she at least has any idea of what she wants.

Please help!!!

Andrea

[shootingstar]

I suddenly felt a little old when reading the age of your mom ...and you're a cycling daughter, presumably? ( I don't have children but my oldest niece is 24 yrs.)

Since she hasn't cycled in several decades and with her current medical problems, it might be a good idea for her to start with a bike where she is in a more upright position. Bike should not be too heavy and no tires that are very knobby. It will slow her down, unless she wants to do off-road trail riding in the woods.

The saddle should be adjustable in height..as well as the position of the saddle (ie. moving the saddle angle up or down).

I know other members here might disagree with me, but most definitely she needs to start with a hybrid bike with several gears...the more gears the better, so that she can make the ride easier on her when the terrain in her riding area changes. Or when she gets better at cycling.

She should visit several local bike stores for bike fit and try cycling their bikes around the block before purchasing anything. No Walmarts. Please don't. She will regret spending her money after she rediscovers her love of biking. She will want a better bike.

[ASammy1]

Thanks shootingstar!

I am a cycling daughter and will be 30 in 2 weeks. She's asking me for help because my father will push her into a bike that is way too advanced for her. He's a techie kinda guy and likes all the latest and greatest advancements. I could see him trying to get her into a road bike w/ drop bars...

[pardes]

I can identify with the arthritis problem. I doubt she will want to be swinging the leg over the seat to get on or off so definitely recommend the most angled top bar.

If she goes with a step-through she will probably be limited with very heavy bikes at the local bike stores. Even though she won't be swinging it up on a bus rack like I do, the heavy bikes just feel clunky.

3 miles doesn't sound like a lot unless you are a new biker who may be a little hesitant about anything but very flat ground. My arhtritis flared today something terrible and it was all I could do to finish 4 miles. Consequently, though she may not think she needs a lot of gears, I think it is very important to get her a bike with really easy granny gears for those terrible days.

I can recommend the PereformanceBike "Soft Tail" Saddle. It's gel, a bit wider but it's definitely not a tractor seat and seems to work perfectly in keeping down the jarring of spinal arthritis pain.

Running around to bike stores is confusing and exhausting for beginners. Have her do a little internet window-shopping.

Here are some ideas:

Trek Women's 7000

'09 Trek Women's Navigator 3.0 This one is heavier than the others but comfortable.

2008 K2 T:Nine Skye Ladies Comfort Bike

GT Transeo

Is there any way you can visit her and take her bike shopping? She would love that!

[OakLeaf]

I assume the RA has affected her hands, as is typical?

So, ease and comfort in braking and shifting is critical. It might be best for her to get a coaster-brake bike (Dutch style) rather than rely on hand braking. And a careful fitting is definitely in order.

[BleeckerSt_Girl]

If she lives in a flat area like Iowa or Florida she's not going to need very many gears, and in fact it might just be frustrating for her to have them. If flat, 3-7 gears should be plenty.

A 3 mile commute is not very long, so it's important to get her a simple bike she LIKES and feels she can control, with the idea that she might want something more 'intimidating' later if she takes to biking. She can always sell her first bike.

I agree that if the bike comes with big honkin' knobby tires, have them switched to lighter tires as a condition of sale. She's not going to be barreling down any mountain trails any time soon, and it'll be hard enough for her as it is to push along until she's in better shape. On a smooth paved road, knobbies won't give her any more traction than smooth light tires...in fact maybe even less. You might want to put Kevlar/flat resistant tires on her bike though, to give her a better chance of not getting a flat.

Yes she needs a more upright bike- a hybrid or a touring type bike would be good. Comfort bikes are 'ok' if they are not too heavy. And watch out for big puffy foam saddles- they can be very painful! Beginners tend to like straight bars with clearly numbered shifting on the handlegrips. No harm in this for 3 mile commutes.

You might want to get her to read this or print it out for her to read:
http://bicyclesafe.com/

[Kano]

DH commutes on his Specialized Expedition and seems to really like it. His ride is about 10 miles one way and hilly. He's got armadillo tires and could probably also use some slime in at least the front tube.

On the other hand, I do not like MY Expedition at all for that kind of riding. The "spongy" feeling that goes with the suspension stuff that is supposed to make it more comfortable doesn't work for me.

I like my little "ancient" hybrid Trek aside from the weight of it. I'm using it to carry stuff like groceries - sometimes with a trailer. Someday if I get more serious about that I may invest in a lighter version, but the hybrid is definitely a good choice with smooth tires. Sometimes you see "city" or touring tires with a bit more tread than road bike tires and that might be nice for if she has a gravelly ride. It can also help with the confidence we sometimes lack in those smooth tires when starting out!

(I have a Specialized Dolce saddle on the Trek. It was nice on the Expedition too)

Karen in Boise

[newfsmith]

I started commuting 8-9 years ago, now I'm retired, so I have license to give advice full time. I am not a fan of twist-shifters. One winter I rode a bike with twist shifters and had wrist pain all winter that took months to go away. It has never come back since I sold that bike and have stuck to either flat bar or drop shifters of the conventional styles.

I absolutely think that the first priority has to be a frame that fits her, but if she is not too short or too tall, the bikes with flat foot technology might be a good choice if her hips are affected.

There are advantages to internal-geared hubs for commuting, most importantly the ability to shift gears while stopped. The Dual-Drive systems combine a triple chain-ring with an 8 speed IG rear hub, giving 24 gears, but still allowing you to down shift from a stop.

There is a trade-off with a front-suspension, you do lose some power, so it is important that your gearing makes up for that.

Another option to consider for brakes would be disc brakes. If she is going to commute in wet weather, they are ideal and I feel they require less grip strength.

Finally, don't count your Dad out completely. Get him on board in researching the available options and what might work best for her special needs.

Bikes I would suggest looking for
http://www.breezerbikes.com/index.cf...TOKEN=81605061
especially the Town bikes and new Finesse
http://www.giant-bicycles.com/en-US/bikes/lifestyle/
especially the Suede and Transend series
http://www.civiacycles.com/civiacompletebike.php
if she thinks she could use a diamond frame, like the Suedes, this comes fully dressed
http://www.electrabike.com/04/bikes/...06_twn_15.html
the Townies tend to look like they were designed for a little girl, but this isn't too bad if you add your own fenders

[ASammy1]

Wow! You ladies are awesome. Thanks for all the great info.

Now to answer some of your questions...

Oakleaf- the RA is only slightly affecting her hands. She has more trouble with Carpal Tunnel.

Everyone- she will probably have tiny hills (southeast Michigan)

newfsmith- She's 5 ft even, so size might be a problem...

[mimitabby]

Steer her AWAY from the bikes with the giant tractor seats. They are VERY uncomfortable after you sit in them for more than 10 minutes.

[vinbek]

I am the practical one. I would encourage your Mom to buy a nice used bike to start. That way she can figure out if its for her or not- without alot of expense. I would buy a light weight cross bike or mountain bike with slicks - not knobbys. I would change the grips to make them padded and comfortable. I would also sit more upright. She needs a frame that fits comfortably and she can get on and off the saddle easily. Gears are important too. She will want enough gears to spin easily. She should look for a bike that is easy to shift - not all the shifters are easy to reach and maneuver with arthritis. My daughter is 13 and has juvenile rheumatoid arthritis. Certain movements create different types of pain - so she will want to try several out to see where the pressure points are for her. My daughter has trouble with her ankles and fingers right now. And she certainly should pick a style and color that make her grin from ear to ear. Good luck - let us know what she decides.

[shootingstar]

I am not a fan of twist-shifters. One winter I rode a bike with twist shifters and had wrist pain all winter that took months to go away. It has never come back since I sold that bike and have stuck to either flat bar or drop shifters of the conventional styles.

I absolutely think that the first priority has to be a frame that fits her, but if she is not too short or too tall, the bikes with flat foot technology might be a good choice if her hips are affected.

There are advantages to internal-geared hubs for commuting, most importantly the ability to shift gears while stopped. The Dual-Drive systems combine a triple chain-ring with an 8 speed IG rear hub, giving 24 gears, but still allowing you to down shift from a stop.

There is a trade-off with a front-suspension, you do lose some power, so it is important that your gearing makes up for that.

Another option to consider for brakes would be disc brakes. If she is going to commute in wet weather, they are ideal and I feel they require less grip strength.

Finally, don't count your Dad out completely. Get him on board in researching the available options and what might work best for her special needs.

Bikes I would suggest looking for
http://www.breezerbikes.com/index.cf...TOKEN=81605061
especially the Town bikes and new Finesse
http://www.giant-bicycles.com/en-US/bikes/lifestyle/
especially the Suede and Transend series
http://www.civiacycles.com/civiacompletebike.php
if she thinks she could use a diamond frame, like the Suedes, this comes fully dressed
http://www.electrabike.com/04/bikes/...06_twn_15.html
the Townies tend to look like they were designed for a little girl, but this isn't too bad if you add your own fenders

Definitely would not recommend handlebar twist gear-shifters. For anyone who is abit weaker hand strength. (and for anyone with a smaller hand grip circumference). I've rented bikes like that and hate them.

Disc brakes are nice...but not frequently found in many bikes for beginners and do add more money to the price tag.

[kpokla]

I am over 50 and have ra....a step thru is ideal. I have a redline and love it! I have 21 gears, but 10 would suffice nicely with "little hills". Also, a Brooks saddle is absolutely wonderful....wish I had bought mine years and years ago.
I hope your Mom enjoys it. The more I pedal the less I hurt. k