I ended up giving up my long finger nails for rock climbing. There's just no compromise there; long nails and climbing just don't mix. Regardless of my nails, I have largish hands and long fingers and I have a terrible time finding women's gloves to fit. If I try enough, I can sometimes find one that'll work. Other times I settle for men's.

How much too short do gloves tend to be for you? If it's only a little bit would you consider shortening your nails some without giving them up completely?

My problem isn't my nails, but I definitely feel your pain.