Bike not quite right -sell??

[seastar]

Hi Ladies,

I have a Trek 2.1 WSD 2010 model. It doesn't feel quite right, I've had it fitted numerous time as LBS...

I bought a second bike for CX. It's a Specialized Crux. I feel more stable and confident on this bike. And I like it a lot more and it's the bike I normally reachfor... It fits great. Only problem is it has CX/bumpy tires (although I could swap those out for the summer). And it's a bit harder to pedal up hills.

So I am wondering - do I need two bikes? And if yes, would I be better off selling the Trek and getting another bike? If I sell and get another bike - aluminium or do I really need a Carbon bike?

Thanks for the help!!

[ny biker]

What feels wrong about the Trek 2.1? And what kind of rides do you use a road bike for?

[seastar]

What feels wrong about the Trek 2.1? And what kind of rides do you use a road bike for?

Not sure exactly. It doesn't feel very sturdy and I feel too small. And shifting feels clunky.

As for riding - I do a 80-100km ride on the weekend and usually a shorter midweek ride of about 40-60km (10km laps), and I'm thinking to do some races this summer.

[emily_in_nc]

Not sure exactly. It doesn't feel very sturdy and I feel too small. And shifting feels clunky.

Sounds like you need a good bike fitting from the LBS where you bought it. And a tune-up for the shifting. Don't sell the bike without giving the shop a chance to make it right. It may be a very simple problem.

[Bethany1]

You can never have enough bikes. Different bikes do different things.

For the clunking, take it to your LBS and make sure it's in working order. If you decide to sell it, best to know now if something is wrong.

If you've had numerous fittings (same LBS or different ones?) maybe something is up. I had several fittings with my Madone. In the end I realized I hadn't truly bonded with the bike. I was sad when I sold it to pay a bill, but I don't regret selling it. It just never felt right and I couldn't put it into words.

How long have you had the bike?

Is there another bike that has caught your eye? Sometimes I think as we get better or more experienced, our needs/fits change. Maybe you've just outgrown this bike and it's time to move on.

I wouldn't sell the bike unless you find something else you are sure you want. Buyers remorse sucks. Then use the money from the bike to purchase the new one.

If anything, if your Crux goes into the shop, you do have a back up bike.

[Owlie]

Two bikes are good, if for no other reason than having a backup.

I'd say get it tuned up to make sure everything's good. Is there a difference in the components between the Crux and the Trek? Also a good fitting. Spendy, possibly, but worth it. Other things...how long have you had the Trek?

[zoom-zoom]

I don't know what it is about CX bikes, but mine is my favorite...and it's a HUGE step-down in fanciness from my road bike. But it fits me better and I love that I can go anywhere with it, even if it's heavier and the knobby, squishy tires don't go nearly as fast. I never really have bad rides on that bike. And I usually get muddy, which is fun!

I'll echo what others have said about the fitting. Do it!

[laura*]

Plus, your comment that it feels too dainty struck me. ... Also, the fact that it feels too small. ... Or does it feel like the bike was made for someone much more petite?

I think she feels the bike is too big. She wrote:


It doesn't feel very sturdy and I feel too small.

[emily_in_nc]

If the bike is truly too big (and you've had a GOOD fitting), then it probably should be sold. Riding a too-big bike is not good.

[seastar]

Thanks!!

I have a refit tomorrow and then a tune up scheduled. The bike has shimano 105 and the cx bike has sram apex.

I have changed the saddle and also the handlebars (to narrower one's)

[Kubla]

Just found this thread -and am curious about the outcome?

Even if you ultimately decide to part company, you will do so knowing you gave the 'relationship' a fair chance and are selling the bike in ready-to-ride shape.

[Jaynee Beyond]

Hello, I am trying to quickly sort out which Nike would be best. I have a chronic heart condition and will need a heart transplant one day. I have a Madone but find it too hard to lean down, so I can't currently use it. I can't use any bike for long, maybe 10 - 15 minutes. It would be a sweet ride regardless. I need a fairly light weight, dependable bike, and upright. Have any of you ridden the Trek 7.4 WSD? If so, how do you like this bike? Do you recommend it? Do you think this bike or another one would best suit my needs. Don't want to spend more than $1,000.00 as it is secondary bike. Thanks for your help.

[pinsonp2]

The Trek FX series are good dependable bikes. I have a 2010 7.5 FX WSD and it is fairly lightweight (it is heavier than a Madone) and rides well. Mine does have the carbon fork which helps with the road buzz. The only issue I have is with right hand numbness, which I have on all flat bar bikes. This may not be an issue for you. Have you approached your LBS to see if they would be willing to raise the bars on the Madone for you (a sacrilige but doable on some models)? You also might look at other brands that get good reviews such as the Giant Dash and the Specialized Vita.

Good luck,
P2