This past month I did a big bike search and ended up with the Bianchi Iseo. I love it. It's absolutely perfect for what I do - commuting, riding on paved bike trails around my city, etc.
Honestly, though, I would not even consider purchasing a bike without a test-ride. I had my heart set on one of the Trek FX models, and when I finally got around to riding one, I really hated it. Nice bike, but it just didn't fit my body and style of riding. The Bianchi was perfect from moment one, and I couldn't be more satisfied.
Best of luck!