you are only ever going to get one answer from me because I am a ground effect chick through and through (I am even wearing a ground effect fleece as I type this in the Christchurch airport Koru lounge). I got five years happy use out of my flash gordon. Last year I bought a new She Shell (I still think that is the coolest name for a womens specific rain jacket) to take on the Great Victorian Bike Ride. It only rained one day on that trip but the She Shell seemed really good. I think the toss up between the She Shell (or the Storm Trooper is you prefer a baggier cut) and the Flash Gordon would depend mostly on if you want a hood. I've also got a Phantom that I wear for commuting. I wear it as much for visibility now that it is getting darker as for rain protection. That being said, even though it is only described as 'resisting light drizzle it has always been adequate rain protection (but my commute is only 10 minutes).
Actually I think that might be three answers