I have Shimano spd pedals and Lake shoes. My cleats look like the ones in your "regular cleats" photo. In your "hung up cleats" photo, it appears there's a notch of some kind at the bottom of the cleat. Or is that just a shadow or discoloration? If it is a notch, then I'd wonder if you got a funky cleat via ebay. Since cleats are sold with the pedals, I'd assume that Shimano could provide replacements so you can put them on your Lakes and ditch the funky ones.