pedals debate....

Printable View

05-12-2008, 07:30 AM
atombessy

pedals debate....

Hi ladies! I thought this question might do better here than in the equipment thread area....I'm possibly going back to clipped in pedals after a sabbatical on flat pedals, and I've got it down to two options, they are:

http://www.crankbrothers.com/mallet.php

and the Shimano M647.

Both are platform style pedals that clip in on either side. I got the Shimano recommendation from reading this board, but two important mt biking dudes in my life insist on the crank brothers. My major priority is something I can get out of easily because I'm a BIG klutz. Any yays or nays in favor of either? I know the Shimano will get some support but I'm curious if anyone has used the mallet as well....
05-12-2008, 07:37 AM
Trekhawk

I am a huge fan of Crank Brothers.
I don't have mallets but I run egg beaters on my mtb and quattros on my road bike.

I am a complete clutz on my mtb and the egg beaters allow me to get out fast.

The mallets look like egg beaters with a platform so they should be super easy to clip in and out of.

Good luck with your pedal hunt.:)
05-12-2008, 07:42 AM
mimitabby

I have spd's and they are fit very loosely. when i need to get out i can pull both feet pretty much any direction.

I like those pedals you showed a photo of though!
05-12-2008, 07:49 AM
oxysback

Hubby and I ride on various Crank Bros pedals. I had egg beaters for awhile, but just got a pair of red Candy C's for Mother's Day. Tried them out for the first time this morning on my commute to work. Love them!

Hubby has Quattros on his recumbent trike and loves them, as well. :)

Very easy in and out...and it doesn't matter if you get them muddy. I also like that the cleats work with any of Crank Bros pedals.
05-12-2008, 08:49 AM
SalsaMTB

I use egg beaters and highly recommend. DH uses mallets on his commuting bike and loves them.
05-12-2008, 10:25 AM
bounceswoosh

Quote:

Originally Posted by atombessy

Hi ladies! I thought this question might do better here than in the equipment thread area....I'm possibly going back to clipped in pedals after a sabbatical on flat pedals, and I've got it down to two options, they are:

http://www.crankbrothers.com/mallet.php

and the Shimano M647.

Both are platform style pedals that clip in on either side. I got the Shimano recommendation from reading this board, but two important mt biking dudes in my life insist on the crank brothers. My major priority is something I can get out of easily because I'm a BIG klutz. Any yays or nays in favor of either? I know the Shimano will get some support but I'm curious if anyone has used the mallet as well....

I adore the M647 -- but I'm guessing it's my post you saw in the first place. But I have never tried anything but SPD, so I can't compare them to the mallets =/ I did find the M647 a lot easier to get in and out of than my previous SPD pedals -- I don't know if that's because they are higher end, because the platform somehow channels my foot into the right place, or what.
05-12-2008, 11:41 AM
bluebug32

Instead of the mallets, you may want to look into a set of Crank Bros. Acids. They have the larger platform like the Mallet, but are much lighter and don't hurt as much when you bash them into your shins (like the mallets do). The Candy is my favorite, however, and has a nice platform too and is easy to get in and out of. Most of pedals will be a little stiff at first (esp. if the cleats are new too), so just give them time to loosen up. I got rid of my SPDs because they were always really loose! Good to learn on, but almost dangerous because my foot would unclip when I was trying to go over logs or big stuff.
05-12-2008, 12:00 PM
Zen

How are the Crank Bros. in terms of float?
05-12-2008, 12:23 PM
atombessy

Hmmm....and what is float? lol
05-12-2008, 12:29 PM
bounceswoosh

First page google hit on "pedal float" looks pretty good":

http://archive.roadbikereview.com/04/0EFCD16A.php
05-12-2008, 12:51 PM
bluebug32

Quote:

Originally Posted by zencentury

How are the Crank Bros. in terms of float?

Pretty good float, esp. the candies.
05-12-2008, 01:01 PM
atombessy

aha, the shimano pedals I have on my road bike are kinda wiggly like that. I also have them as loose as they go though! (I do'nt know what kind they are, they're husband cast offs that are probably ten years old, but they don't have a flat platform).

I think it's going to end up being the Crank Bros at this point.... thank you for the advice ladies!! I'll let you know how they work out. Might be another month though, I have to save up for new mt bike shoes too :)
05-12-2008, 02:32 PM
Zen

Quote:

Originally Posted by bluebug32

Pretty good float, esp. the candies.

I'm looking for something for a canal bike. I need float and a big platform. If I could just combine my Frogs with some Wellgo's :o
05-12-2008, 03:35 PM
carback

I recently switched to Crank Bros Candy pedals, after several years on Shimano platform type SPDs.

I ride in a very muddy part of the world (and sometimes snowy) and found the cleats on the SPDS would get clogged with mud (I walk super technical stuff) and snow and be impossible to clip into and out of.

After a particularly bad session of the above a couple of weeks ago, I switched to the Candy's. there was a bit of a learning curve in terms of ease of clipping back in but otherwise think they're great. If the tread on your shoe is quite aggressive, you might need to shave a bit of sole off (with a rasp or really rough sandpaper) in order to clip in / out easier.

Good luck.
05-16-2008, 04:23 PM
ima_bleeder

Living in the northwest I wouldn't use the Shimano's for mountain biking because I ride year-round, and it gets difficult to clip back in with mud packed in your cleat. With the CB pedals you can jam your foot down and the mud drops through.

I've got the regular eggbeaters, and love them. I'm able to get in and out easily.

Look has a mountain bike pedal too that has an interesting design. Pretty open, like the eggbeaters. I'm interested, but not interested enough to start trying out new pedals right now.
05-18-2008, 04:45 AM
MtnBikerChk

Quote:

Originally Posted by zencentury

I'm looking for something for a canal bike. I need float and a big platform. If I could just combine my Frogs with some Wellgo's :o

why not try the speedplay x2s? Not the biggest platform but the most float!
05-22-2008, 03:37 PM
CarbonCandy

Used both SPDs and Crank Bros.

Crank Bros win my vote by far. I've got Egg Beaters and Candy pedals and they are both fantastic. The movement I get in them is great. On the spds I just felt too locked in.

Possibly getting Acids or Mallets, for the future fs :]
05-24-2008, 10:13 AM
TahoeDirtGirl

ok ready for big dumb question?

The least of my favorite things is pedals. I bought spds because of peer pressure. I have ridden on platforms (no clipless) for a long time because of a bad knee and now a foot that no one seems to know what to do with (it got jammed between two rocks- good thing it wasn't clipped in bc it would of gotten broken. Anyway, I was looking for a pedal that you can clip in one side, and have a platform on the other. I have a set right now on my commuter that are 'gym quality' because that's all I could find. Would these do the same? I would like to put them on my mtb 'some day' as yes, you do go a bit faster, but right now I'm still rehabbing the foot and let me tell you, clipless is painful.

I can't really tell from the pic if these can be flipped around. And it sounds like you guys know your pedals!
05-24-2008, 07:53 PM
CarbonCandy

Quote:

Originally Posted by TahoeDirtGirl

Anyway, I was looking for a pedal that you can clip in one side, and have a platform on the other.

Flat on one side, shimano spd of the other

Shimano 324 pedal ---> http://www.globalbikesonline.com/cat...24%20pedal.jpg
05-24-2008, 07:54 PM
Trekhawk

Quote:

Originally Posted by TahoeDirtGirl

The least of my favorite things is pedals. I bought spds because of peer pressure. I have ridden on platforms (no clipless) for a long time because of a bad knee and now a foot that no one seems to know what to do with (it got jammed between two rocks- good thing it wasn't clipped in bc it would of gotten broken. Anyway, I was looking for a pedal that you can clip in one side, and have a platform on the other. I have a set right now on my commuter that are 'gym quality' because that's all I could find. Would these do the same? I would like to put them on my mtb 'some day' as yes, you do go a bit faster, but right now I'm still rehabbing the foot and let me tell you, clipless is painful.

I can't really tell from the pic if these can be flipped around. And it sounds like you guys know your pedals!

I do not own Mallets but I think you can clip in on both sides which is not what you are after.
Shimano have some that are platform on one side clip in on the other. Have a look here:
http://www.sheldonbrown.com/harris/pedals.html

Good luck with your pedal hunt.:)
05-29-2008, 05:06 PM
TahoeDirtGirl

Thanks for the links! I have regular flats on my mtbike and the combo ones on my commuter bike. I don't mind clipping in commuting but mtn biking, no deal. Either way I'm not supposed to until they figure out what happened to the foot. SPDs have a lot of float but it doesn't help the foot.