I agree, Grog - REAL peanut butter, like Crazy Richard's. Ingredients: peanuts. Yes, it's a pain to stir when you first open the jar, and no, there is no salt so the taste is different, but it is so much better. I eat it rarely, though, so I can't blame peanut butter for my extra pounds...:(
I also agree with drinking lots of water (I add a slice of lemon to mine), eating oatmeal with no sugar (I add things like raisins, dried cranberries, fresh blueberries, sliced almonds or walnuts.) I buy only fresh ingredients and make most everything from scratch. When I eat meat it is usually chicken breast, salmon or ground turkey. Red meat 1x month - though I could probably eat a nice slab of steak once a week if I would let myself. I use low-fat yogurt, vanilla flavor because I just can't eat plain. Fat free salad dressings. All the right stuff - and I still can't get that extra 15 lb. off!
One downfall I have is that dinner is almost always late in the evening - say, 8 p.m. By the time my SO and I get home from work & work out & shower, it's after 7, then time to fix dinner. If only I could work 4 hours/day instead of 8 - oh, and get paid the same, if not more :D then maybe I could get dinner on the table earlier!
It is comforting to see that I am not the only one carrying extra pounds & wrestling with the same issues! I love this forum & having this "sisterhood"!