Not all bike shops have the memory foam, or agree with it...
Printable View
Not all bike shops have the memory foam, or agree with it...
Don't agree with it -- meaning they don't think it gives an accurate or usable measurement?Quote:
Originally Posted by Catrin
I had great results with the yoga mat method, but that could just be luck.
It's a great question! I've tried sitting on wet paper (bad idea) and then sitting on dry paper with a ballpoint pen in my hand, trying to trace (worse idea--my husband was really puzzled by how I ended up with ink all over my bottom). Playdoh, a bag of flour, or the yoga mat never occurred to me!
How do you measure any other part of your body?
Use a cloth (or plastic) measure. Use one hand to hold the 0 end on one butt point and use the other hand to pinch the part of the tape over your other butt point.
If you got the same measurement again and again with all the suggested methods, maybe you just have sitbones that match a giraffe pelvis in the third trimester?Quote:
Originally Posted by Chicken Little
(mine are 170-190mm, and my hips themselves are not very wide. Sit bone width and hip width don't have much to do with each other)
ahhhh.. i wonder if painting my butt lightly with my daughter's washable paints, and then sitting on paper (a la stamping) will work... :rolleyes:
Ditto this.Quote:
Originally Posted by malkin
Hold a fabric measuring tape in one hand. Lie on your back and flip your legs into the air (kind of over your head but you don't need to go that far). Feel for the sit bones and then hold the tape at each bone point. Flip upright without letting go of the tape and read your measurement. Voila!
I never had luck with the sitting on gel-like things as I have way to much butt padding to get a good reading.
I was surprised at how narrow my sit bones were. I always thought that being a big bottomed girl meant that I had wide hips. Not so much (which explains why my thighs will ALWAYS touch no matter how thin I get!). :p
Ditto...all of it. Even when I was a size 2 (by modern sizing) in HS I wore the inner thighs of my jeans out fast. At the time I was all of 115#s at 5'3"ish.Quote:
Originally Posted by GLC1968
I think making an impression is better than using a tape measure, because the sitbones aren't parallel to the sagittal plane. An impression gives you not only the inside and outside measurements, but the angle.
And I think the inner thigh rub has to do with Q-angle and adductor development. It's an issue for me and my moderately wide bones, too.
I am thinking the water base paint thing might work. I'm trying it this weekend.
I tried the yoga mat method, but it didn't work for me. maybe i should have been sitting there a bit longer, will try again.Quote:
Originally Posted by pinkbikes
as for my 2 Ariel saddles, I don't notice much difference. But then they are on my mountainbikes, where I spend more time standing on the pedals or just leaning my legs against the saddle, not really sitting on it like on the road bike. And I rarely spend more than 2 hours on my mountainbikes (unlike the road which I use for much longer trips).
Just wanted to ditto this - there really is very little correlation. I have narrow hips but quite wide sitbones. Yesterday I saw a rare pic of me biking taken from behind and it was actually visible, both the wide "seating" and the thigh bone that seemingly goes straight down.Quote:
Originally Posted by KnottedYet
Me too with the wide sit/narrow hip.
In fact, it feels like the distance between my sit bones is wider than the distance from either one of them to the outside world on the side.
[QUOTE=Zelda_K;518406]I tried the yoga mat method, but it didn't work for me. maybe i should have been sitting there a bit longer, will try again./QUOTE]
I was semi-successful using a mat. I folded it in fourths and put it on my dining room table, which has a marble top. The impressions don't last for long but I was able to get a outside to outside measurement that is similar to what I got when I just took a tape measure to my up-ended butt.
It looks like I'm measuring around 130-135 mm. My current saddle is 155 (or maybe 160?) and it's comfortable for me, so that makes sense.
BTW my current saddle is pretty close to perfect, but is wearing out (cover is cracking) so I need a new one. Sadly they don't make the one I have anymore, so I'm going to post pics of it in a separate thread in the hopes that someone can point me towards a new one with a similar shape.
Yoga mats tend to be thin and rather firm. I had good luck with a floorwork mat that's maybe 8 mm - 1 cm thick.
Remember to sit low enough (or elevate your feet enough) that your femurs and thigh flesh aren't keeping your sitbones from making a good impression.