late to this thread, sorry!
Hi Melody -
Next time you pass the Outfitter and have the urge to look in ( it's hard to resist :) ), take a look at the Shimano sandals. The size 43-44 might be just right for you. They're 'mountain-bike' style, that is, the cleats are recessed and they're relatively easy to walk around in. Very nice to wear in the summer, and when it's cooler you can wear them with socks.
Shimano sandals are a look that some like, some don't. Lake also makes sandals but I've never tried them.
I would love my Shimano sandals but my feet are a bit on the narrow size so I need to wear a thick innersole along with them, which kindof-sortof-not really works, and I'd rather wear them w/o socks. I wish they made them in slightly narrower widths (say, women's medium width).