Originally Posted by
boy in a kilt
Here are a couple of things to try.
First off, check the fore/aft orientation of your cleats. A good starting point is just under the ball of your foot. If the pain stays or gets work, move them back (to under the arch) a little bit at a time.
Secondly, check the centering on them. If your cleats are positioned to make your toes point inward and your toes naturally want to point outward, it may be causing undue pressure on the area in question.
Finally, check your arches and insteps. I have wicked high arches and the instep to match. After cycling for 25 years with my toes frequently going numb, I switched to a set of Sidi Megas. Problem solved. A bit of arch support might help.