KnottedYet I think you might be the winner!
First, thanks for all the replies.
I took my toenail polish off my left big toe, expecting to see some sort of bruise or something. Nothing. Poking, prodding, looking for an ingrown toenail (which I've never had so I thought some of you might be on to something). Again, nothing. Still hurts though.
While walking into work this morning I tried to picture where my toes were in relation to my shoe and foot. I have narrow feet always fit comfortably in my ballet shoes when taking dance. I wear a 7.5 in Nike and an 8 in some other shoes. There is always enough room in the toe box for all my little piggies.
Maybe I'm like Knotted, they just point up naturally.
It's still hurting though, if it hurts after this weekend's century I WILL call my doc for a referral!
Jeni