PDA

View Full Version : Visibility-what price glory. Light review {long}



tzvia
07-11-2010, 08:06 PM
Visibility. How the heck do I lessen the chance I will get creamed in an intersection in the dark. How do I make my self noticeable at a good distance in daylight to a driver who may be distracted or tired. Back in December as I contemplated becoming a commuter, these two questions always came up. Aside from reflectors and hi-viz vests, I would need lights, but what kind and how much.

I started with a Sefras AAA headlight and Viewpoint blinkie in the rear. Not enough. In the dark, not enough up front to light the road surface and too dim to compete with car headlamps. I needed lumens. The rear blinkie fared better but it could not compete with the city and all the cars. After some research, and adding a second rear blinkie, (a Blackburn Mars 3), I came to the conclusion I needed closer to 3 watts in back for it to be noticeable in daylight like a car brake light. Then the Blackburn broke at the mount, then the Viewpoint. (within 2 weeks of each other). They are probably swimming in the Pacific by now. I was through with AAA blinkies.

After researching lights, I found out about 'Magicshine' lights. And they just came out with a rear taillight that works on an external lith-ion rechargeable battery. 3 watts. They also have a 900 Lumen (supposed) front light. So I bought both online from 'Geoman Gear', along with a Y cable to run both lights from one battery. So far, I am pleased with the lights. A co-worker who passed me in his truck last week went out of his way to stop me outside my office to comment that he saw me blinking all the way down the block, well before he got close to me. This was in daylight. On the way home, when I stopped at a light, a person standing there commented he saw my headlight (in blink mode) all the way down the street- in broad daylight, on a long city block.

I had bought a L&M Stella 150 before finding out about the Magischine, and although it is a well made light, it is only good as a nighttime 'be seen light'. It was not enough to be a main front light for daylight use or at night if you wish to see the road. The Magicshine blows it away. The cost is reasonable too, I got the front and rear lights, Y cable and two batteries for about 20 bucks more than the Stella 150.

The other really useful light I found started out as a silly thing but it is really very useful in the 'be seen at night' category. It's the 'BikeGlow' safety light. Silly looking, but it really works. I found it at the local REI. It's a thin tube that is about 3feet long and glows (2AA batteries). You wrap it around the frame and secure it with zip ties. At night, the light makes you visible as a cyclist from the sides. No it's not as bright as a rear blinkie, but that's not what it is for. And it's cool looking.

So I would recommend the Magicshine front and rear lights to any commuter who wants daylight visible front and rear lighting at a reasonable price, without the hassle of AA and AAA batteries. And if you want to have some fun in the dark (with lights :D) the BikeGlow adds some side visibility and color.

Don't forget the reflectors and hi-vis vest, and be safe out there...

Zen
07-12-2010, 07:55 AM
Thanks for that review.
i will definitely investigate that light.

ETA-
here's (http://www.candlepowerforums.com/vb/showthread.php?t=261836) a discussion of the Magicshine

colorisnt
07-12-2010, 06:10 PM
I don't commute at night, but I do during the day. LOTS of reflectors and even more reflective tape. I don't have a high vis vest, but have a bright white helmet with reflective tape. My ghetto storage bucket panniers are getting HUGE amounts of reflective tape put on this wee. I also have a blinky light.

If you miss me, you are oblivious!

Zen
07-12-2010, 06:14 PM
If you miss me, you are oblivious!

So does that mean if someone hits you they're paying attention?;)

bikerchic
07-12-2010, 10:17 PM
So does that mean if someone hits you they're paying attention?;)

Oh dear! Must have been a typo?

Thanks for the light review, best to be seen and not heard......bikes are so quiet compared to cars, LOL.

trista
07-13-2010, 05:39 PM
Thanks for the review! I've been looking at this light b/c I'm trying to set up good system on my bike as the days get a little shorter each day.

I don't understand how the helmet mount works - would I have to have a cord coming off my helmet to the battery pack below or does the battery pack also mount to the helmet? How big is the battery pack?

Zen
07-13-2010, 05:49 PM
here's (http://www.candlepowerforums.com/vb/showthread.php?t=261836) a discussion of the Magicshine
___

tzvia
07-13-2010, 06:19 PM
Thanks for the review! I've been looking at this light b/c I'm trying to set up good system on my bike as the days get a little shorter each day.

I don't understand how the helmet mount works - would I have to have a cord coming off my helmet to the battery pack below or does the battery pack also mount to the helmet? How big is the battery pack?

They have two battery packs- the same battery but one is encased in a metal tube about 3.5" long by 2" wide to make it water proof (not optimal for mounting on the helmet). The metal cased one comes with the front light, the one without comes with the rear light. I use that one as it weighs less. I did buy some 'Plasticdip' at Home Depot and dipped the non water proof battery in it to encase it in a rubber jacket so it is now waterproof. It lasts for 6 40minute commutes a week running both lights with the Y cable with no problem. The battery is sized like what 4 or 5 AA batteries would look like in a square holder, not big and not as heavy.

The helmet mount is optional and yes the power cord would then run to the battery which could go in a jersey pocket, or be velcroed to the helmet if you don't mind the weight. If I were going mountain biking with it I would mount the light on the helmet but I think it makes more sense on the handlebar for commuting as it is less hassle. Just run and ziptie your cables and the Y cord, connect up both lights and go.

I still can't get over how cars pulling out of parking lots and side streets see me coming and actually back up and I get a wide birth from behind. These lights are bright.

Melalvai
07-14-2010, 12:08 PM
There are a lot of threads about lights. I like the Downlow Glow from http://www.rockthebike.com. For someone who travels at night a lot, a generator hub or sidewall generator produces a very bright light, without having to worry about batteries.

I really like the battery-free options. I hate going through lots of AA batteries, which defeat all the environmental friendliness of a bike. I mean, that's not why I ride a bike, but it is a perk that I like.

trista
07-14-2010, 03:48 PM
They have two battery packs- the same battery but one is encased in a metal tube about 3.5" long by 2" wide to make it water proof (not optimal for mounting on the helmet). The metal cased one comes with the front light, the one without comes with the rear light. I use that one as it weighs less. I did buy some 'Plasticdip' at Home Depot and dipped the non water proof battery in it to encase it in a rubber jacket so it is now waterproof. It lasts for 6 40minute commutes a week running both lights with the Y cable with no problem. The battery is sized like what 4 or 5 AA batteries would look like in a square holder, not big and not as heavy.

The helmet mount is optional and yes the power cord would then run to the battery which could go in a jersey pocket, or be velcroed to the helmet if you don't mind the weight. If I were going mountain biking with it I would mount the light on the helmet but I think it makes more sense on the handlebar for commuting as it is less hassle. Just run and ziptie your cables and the Y cord, connect up both lights and go.

I still can't get over how cars pulling out of parking lots and side streets see me coming and actually back up and I get a wide birth from behind. These lights are bright.

Thanks! I ordered a set and got the helmet mount too... I'm not sure if I will put it on my helmet or not but I wanted to have the option.

DH is very concerned about me biking in the dark :rolleyes:. So hopefully with this light, another front light (planet bike), a helmet mounted blinky, 2 long and bright red flashies on the frame, countless reflector stickers on the wheels, plus sewn reflectors on my jerseys, he'll feel a little better. At this point I think I'll be visible from the moon.

Anyway, thanks for the review - I've been trying to decide on a rechargeable set but so many were out of my price range. I can't wait to get it!

trista
07-26-2010, 01:10 PM
Hey Tzvia, I have been using this light for nearly 2 weeks and I love it! Thanks for the review. I've got it on my helmet and it lights up the road as well as a car's lights IMO. It's BRIGHT!